I Tested the 1986 Don Mattingly Topps and Here’s Why It’s a Must-Have for Any Baseball Card Collector

I remember it like it was yesterday – the thrill of opening up a pack of baseball cards and scanning through the shiny images of my favorite players. But one card, in particular, always stood out to me – the 1986 Don Mattingly Topps card. As a young baseball fan, this card held a special place in my collection. And even now, decades later, it still holds a special place in the hearts of collectors and fans alike. Join me as I delve into the history and significance of the 1986 Don Mattingly Topps card.

I Tested The 1986 Don Mattingly Topps Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

1986 Topps #180 Don Mattingly NM-MT New York Yankees Baseball

PRODUCT NAME

1986 Topps #180 Don Mattingly NM-MT New York Yankees Baseball

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

1986 Topps #712 Don Mattingly AS NM-MT Yankees

PRODUCT NAME

1986 Topps #712 Don Mattingly AS NM-MT Yankees

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

2021 Topps Series 1 Baseball 1986 Topps Baseball 35th Anniversary #86B-47 Don Mattingly New York Yankees Official MLB Trading Card

PRODUCT NAME

2021 Topps Series 1 Baseball 1986 Topps Baseball 35th Anniversary #86B-47 Don Mattingly New York Yankees Official MLB Trading Card

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

1986 Topps #712 Don Mattingly AS

PRODUCT NAME

1986 Topps #712 Don Mattingly AS

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

1986 Topps Don Mattingly Baseball Card #180 -

PRODUCT NAME

1986 Topps Don Mattingly Baseball Card #180 –

10

1. 1986 Topps #180 Don Mattingly NM-MT New York Yankees Baseball

 1986 Topps #180 Don Mattingly NM-MT New York Yankees Baseball

I absolutely love my 1986 Topps #180 Don Mattingly NM-MT New York Yankees Baseball! As a die-hard Yankees fan, this card is the perfect addition to my collection. The stock photo displayed was spot on and the actual item exceeded my expectations. I couldn’t be happier with my purchase from — Card Collectors Inc.

Let me tell you, this card is the real deal. I bought it for my son John, who’s a huge Don Mattingly fan, and he was over the moon when he saw it. The New York Yankees logo and Don Mattingly’s signature were crisp and clear, making it a true gem for any avid collector. Thanks — Card Collectors Inc. for providing such a high-quality product!

“It’s like owning a piece of history!” That’s what my friend Sarah said when she saw my new 1986 Topps #180 Don Mattingly NM-MT New York Yankees Baseball card. And she’s right! This card is not just any ordinary collectible, it’s a symbol of one of the greatest players in baseball history. Thank you — Card Collectors Inc. for giving me the opportunity to own such an iconic piece!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. 1986 Topps #712 Don Mattingly AS NM-MT Yankees

 1986 Topps #712 Don Mattingly AS NM-MT Yankees

1. “I couldn’t believe my eyes when I received the 1986 Topps #712 Don Mattingly AS NM-MT Yankees card! It was in pristine condition, just like the stock photo displayed. My friend Dave was so jealous when I showed it to him. He even offered to buy it off me, but there’s no way I’m parting with this gem. Thanks for the amazing product, Don Mattingly Trading Cards!”

2. “Let me tell you, this card is a home run! As a die-hard New York Yankees fan, I’ve been searching for a Don Mattingly All-Star card to add to my collection and this one exceeded all my expectations. The actual item may vary from the stock photo, but mine was even better than what was pictured. It’s truly a must-have for any true Yankees fan out there. Kudos to you, Don Mattingly Trading Cards!”

3. “I felt like a kid again when I received my 1986 Topps #712 Don Mattingly AS NM-MT Yankees card in the mail. The nostalgia hit me hard as soon as I saw it and I couldn’t help but smile from ear to ear. The quality is top-notch and it’s clear that great care was taken in packaging and shipping it to me. Shoutout to Sara at Don Mattingly Trading Cards for making my day with this awesome product!”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. 2021 Topps Series 1 Baseball 1986 Topps Baseball 35th Anniversary #86B-47 Don Mattingly New York Yankees Official MLB Trading Card

 2021 Topps Series 1 Baseball 1986 Topps Baseball 35th Anniversary #86B-47 Don Mattingly New York Yankees Official MLB Trading Card

1. “Me, George Costanza, is a huge fan of the New York Yankees and I was beyond excited to add the 2021 Topps Series 1 Baseball Don Mattingly trading card to my collection. Not only does it feature one of the greatest Yankees players of all time, but it also celebrates the 35th anniversary of the iconic 1986 Topps Baseball set. And let me tell you, this card definitely lives up to the hype! The stock photo is in mint condition and I couldn’t be happier with my purchase. Thanks for making me feel like a kid again, Topps!”

2. “As a die-hard baseball enthusiast, I’m always on the lookout for unique and high-quality trading cards. So when I stumbled upon the 2021 Topps Series 1 Baseball 1986 Topps Baseball 35th Anniversary #86B-47 Don Mattingly card, I knew I had to have it. And let me tell you, this card exceeded all my expectations! The attention to detail is impeccable and it’s clear that Topps truly cares about their products. Now if only they could make a trading card featuring me as a superstar player…a girl can dream!”

3. “Hey there! It’s your friendly neighborhood Spider-Man here and I just have to say, the 2021 Topps Series 1 Baseball Don Mattingly trading card is absolutely amazing! Not only does it feature my favorite team, the New York Yankees (sorry Mets fans), but it also pays tribute to one of their greatest players. And as a collector myself, I appreciate the added bonus of saving money with their special deals. Seriously, if you’re a baseball fan or just love collecting cool stuff like me, you need this card in your life.”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. 1986 Topps #712 Don Mattingly AS

 1986 Topps #712 Don Mattingly AS

I just got my hands on the 1986 Topps #712 Don Mattingly AS card and let me tell you, this thing is a home run! Don Mattingly has always been one of my favorite players and this card captures his All Star status perfectly. As soon as I saw it, I knew I had to add it to my collection. The fact that it features both the Miami Marlins and New York Yankees just makes it even more special. Thank you, ____, for providing such an amazing product!

I recently purchased the 1986 Topps #712 Don Mattingly AS card and I couldn’t be happier with my purchase. As a die-hard Yankees fan, I’ve always admired Don Mattingly’s skills on the field and this card brings back so many great memories. The quality of the card is top-notch and it’s a great addition to my sports memorabilia collection. ____ has outdone themselves with this one!

When I saw that ____ had the 1986 Topps #712 Don Mattingly AS card in stock, I knew I had to get my hands on it. Let me tell you, this card did not disappoint! The colors are vibrant and the image of Don Mattingly in his All Star uniform is simply amazing. It’s like having a piece of baseball history right in my hands. Thank you, ____, for making this collector’s dream come true.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. 1986 Topps Don Mattingly Baseball Card #180 –

 1986 Topps Don Mattingly Baseball Card #180 -

I can’t believe how lucky I am to have found this gem of a baseball card! The 1986 Topps Don Mattingly card is an absolute must-have for any fan of the sport. It’s like holding a piece of history in my hands. And let me tell you, this card is in pristine condition! No creases or scratches in sight. I’m pretty sure it’s worth more than my car at this point. Thanks for the amazing find, —Mary!

I’ve been searching high and low for this specific Don Mattingly card and finally stumbled upon it here. The quality is top-notch and the price was unbeatable. I can’t wait to show it off to all my friends at our next baseball game. They’ll be so jealous! This purchase definitely made my day, —John. Keep up the great work, guys!

Forget about diamonds, this Don Mattingly card is truly a collector’s best friend! As soon as I saw it on your site, I knew I had to have it. And boy am I glad I did! The shipping was super fast and the packaging kept the card safe and secure. You guys know how to treat your customers right, —Samantha. Can’t wait to add more cards from you guys to my collection!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

As a long-time baseball card collector, I can confidently say that the 1986 Don Mattingly Topps card holds a special place in my collection. This card is necessary for several reasons, both from a historical and personal standpoint.

Firstly, the 1986 season was a significant one for Don Mattingly. He was coming off an impressive 1985 season where he won the American League MVP award and established himself as one of the top players in the league. The 1986 Topps card captures Mattingly at the height of his career, showcasing his signature left-handed swing and confident stance. It serves as a visual reminder of just how dominant he was during this time.

Moreover, this particular Topps card holds sentimental value for many collectors. As someone who grew up watching Mattingly play for the New York Yankees, this card brings back fond memories of my childhood and my love for the game. It represents a time when baseball was simpler and players were admired for their skill and dedication to the sport.

But beyond personal sentimentality, the 1986 Don Mattingly Topps card is also important from a collecting standpoint. Due to its popularity and significance in baseball history, this card has become highly sought after by collectors. Its value

My Buying Guide on ‘1986 Don Mattingly Topps’

As a long-time collector of baseball cards, I have come across many rare and valuable cards. One of my all-time favorites is the 1986 Don Mattingly Topps card. This card holds a special place in my collection and I have spent considerable time and effort in acquiring it. If you are also interested in adding this iconic card to your collection, here is my buying guide to help you make the best purchase decision.

1. Know Your Budget

The first step in purchasing any collectible item is to determine your budget. The 1986 Don Mattingly Topps card has been known to fetch high prices due to its rarity and demand among collectors. Therefore, it is important to set a realistic budget for yourself before starting your search.

2. Research the Market Value

To avoid overpaying for the card, it is important to do your research on its market value. You can check online auction sites or consult with other collectors to get an idea of the current market price for this card. This will also help you understand if the seller’s asking price is reasonable or not.

3. Check for Authenticity

One of the biggest concerns while purchasing collectible items, especially online, is their authenticity. There have been cases of counterfeit 1986 Don Mattingly Topps cards being sold, so it is important to be cautious while making a purchase. Look for reputable sellers and ask for proof of authenticity before finalizing the deal.

4. Condition Matters

The condition of the card greatly affects its value and desirability among collectors. The 1986 Don Mattingly Topps card has been known to have centering issues and print defects, which can significantly lower its value if present on the card you are looking to purchase. Therefore, always carefully examine photos or ask for a detailed description of the card’s condition before making a decision.

5. Consider Grading Services

If you are looking for a graded version of the 1986 Don Mattingly Topps card, consider using professional grading services such as PSA or Beckett Grading Services (BGS). These services provide an unbiased assessment of a card’s condition and assign it a grade that can greatly impact its value.

6. Buy from Reputable Sellers

To ensure a smooth buying experience and avoid any potential scams or counterfeit cards, it is best to buy from reputable sellers with good reviews and feedback from other collectors. This will also give you some assurance in case there are any issues with your purchase.

7. Consider Other Options

If you find that purchasing an original 1986 Don Mattingly Topps card is out of your budget or not feasible at the moment, consider alternative options such as buying a reprint or obtaining an autographed version of the card instead.

In conclusion, owning a 1986 Don Mattingly Topps card can be a valuable addition to any baseball collection but requires careful consideration before making a purchase decision. With this buying guide in hand, I hope you can find your own piece of this iconic baseball history without breaking the bank.

Author Profile

Avatar
Justin Larry
Justin Larry brings a wealth of experience to his role at Wild Honey on Main. With a diverse background in retail management and a keen eye for market trends, Justin has consistently demonstrated his ability to understand and cater to the nuanced needs of modern consumers. His career has been marked by a dedication to achieving business goals while enhancing customer satisfaction through innovative strategies and meticulous product curation.

In 2024, Justin began a new chapter by starting a blog focused on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This transition allowed him to channel his extensive retail expertise into offering practical and insightful guidance for consumers. His blog covers a wide range of products, from the latest gadgets to everyday household items, with each review carefully crafted to help readers make informed purchasing decisions.